The Bolivian Referendum: Watershed Moment or Politics as Usual?

01/30/09  Print This Post Print This Post    5 Comments   Popular   Written by Hal Amen
    Share

“Se acabo el colonialismo (Colonialism is over),” declared President Evo Morales as his country voted to adopt a controversial new constitution last Sunday. A powerful sentiment, intensely meaningful for many here in South America’s poorest, most indigenous nation.

For Morales, the passage of the constitution marked the long-awaited fulfillment of a campaign promise that aided his election as Bolivia’s first indigenous president three years ago.

That promise was to redefine how the country viewed its native majority, to erase the privilege bequeathed to the descendants of European conquerors, to create a Bolivia where equal rights for all was a legally enshrined doctrine.

Between then and now, the path to Sunday’s vote had, at times, seemed to slip away. Following political clashes over the drafting of the constitutional document and violent confrontations in the streets that claimed dozens of lives, the referendum was postponed on three separate occasions.

Many feared January 25 would bring more of the same.

Not this time. The vote went off smoothly, praised by both international monitoring agencies and neighboring Latin American leaders happy to witness a peaceful display of Bolivian democracy.

In fact, the entire campaign was marked by a peculiar absence of emotion on the ground. Here in the central highland capital of Cochabamba, a few late rallies, a fair amount of graffiti, and the odd loudspeaker truck kept focus on the issue, but there was none of the passionate collective action that characterizes Bolivian political campaigning, particularly in the age of Evo.

Perhaps everyone was ready for a conclusion.

A tremendous calm settled over the city on Sunday—notably enhanced by the ban on vehicle traffic and alcohol sales—as citizens carried out the solemn obligation of casting a ballot. True to predictions, the “si” contingency won the day with roughly 60% of the vote.

But such tranquility is deceiving.

A closer look at the numbers details a nation starkly divided between the indigenous Andean provinces of the west, which backed the referendum by a ratio of 3 to 1, and the wealthier lowland regions to the east that handed Morales a 2 to 1 reprimand.

And what the campaign lacked in grassroots activity was made up for on the airwaves, ablaze with inflammatory and often utterly irrational rhetoric.

Opposition ads claimed, for instance, that the constitution would abolish Christianity, promote abortion and homosexuality, divvy up all current land holdings, and otherwise transform Bolivia into a rabidly pagan, socialist state.

The truth is that many of the articles originally proposed were so watered down over the months of heated negotiation and political maneuvering that they drew equal criticism from left and right. A rundown of major changes actually included in the document can be found here.

It wouldn’t be inaccurate to suggest that the vote was as much a referendum on Morales himself as the adoption of a new constitution… on his beliefs that the country’s indigenous peoples should be given a greater voice, that the government should exercise greater control over natural resources, that the majority of Bolivians have toiled too long under the yoke of oppression.

Yes, the constitution passed.

The sad reality is this means relatively little. Before anything changes in the day-to-day lives of the people here, before Bolivia can be “decolonized,” Congress must undertake the tedious process of crafting new laws to concretize the principles advocated in the document.

And, with the division between rich and poor, European and native, “no” and “si” unmitigated, that task is going to be as difficult as ever.

Photos: Hal Amen


    Share

About the Author

Matador ID: halamen

Freelance writer and Matador contributor Hal Amen has been an avid traveler for as long as he can remember, and he wouldn't have it any other way. 2009 is his volunteer year in South America, and you can find tales of this and other adventures on his personal travel blog, WayWorded.

More By This Author

5 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Ron in L.A. replied on January 31, 2009

    It's just the beginning. Everyone in the departments like Santa Cruz, Tarija etc. all realized there was no reason to fight over the mostly symbolic vote. Evo will be undone by his own ego and inability to provide for the indigenous people, especially with Chavez's economy going into the tank and Brazil cutting back on its gas imports.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Tim Patterson replied on February 1, 2009

    Nice post, Hal. Are you based in Bolivia now? Or Peru? Or just a traveling man once more?

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Hal replied on February 2, 2009

    Bolivia for the time being, then most likely down on to Patagonia in a few months.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Sarah_Menkedick replied on February 2, 2009

    Hey Hal– I'm not sure I agree that this means relatively little, considering the massive unrest in Bolivia in the past several months…I was so depressed to see the gas and oil interests in Santa Cruz gaining more and more control, and trying (with the cooperation of the U.S through the American ambassador in La Paz) to push Morales out. Seeing that Morales has survived that and has managed to pull off the referendum, peacefully, is inspiring. Even if there is a long, difficult road ahead, I think this is a hopeful moment for Bolivia. It is one of the few Latin American states that I think really has the chance of pulling itself out from under the control of foreign interests (i.e., kicking the French bottled water companies out of Cochabamba.) I don't know, I was in Bolivia in 2004 and 2005 and I thought, out of all the places I traveled in Latin America, that it had the most politically active and motivated indigenous population, and that it also had the greatest chance of building democracy from the bottom up. In Cochabamba hundreds of people gathered every day in the central plaza to read news updates posted on big bulletin boards. Did you see any of that while you were there, or has that changed? By the way, what do you think about the sobriety laws forbidding people from drinking on election weekend?? This is common across Latin America. Good idea? Bad idea? And Hal, let me know if you want any info about Patagonia, it's my favorite place on Earth! I swoon at the thought of those mountains.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Hal replied on February 3, 2009

    Wow, thanks for this, Sarah. While I think the success of the referendum does strike a chord of hope, Santa Cruz et al. continue to make it clear they will have to be dragged kicking and screaming through any major changes. Yet, I agree with you about Bolivia's population being more politically active than most, and this is inspiring. As I noted, referendum campaigning was more subdued than what I was expecting, but I think Cochabambinos are still a pretty informed and involved bunch. 2004-5 were certainly some heady times, though. I can only imagine. As for the drinking ban, I think it's a fantastic idea. Ban on all forms of road transport? Not so logical. In addition, voting is virtually mandatory. You have to show proof of ballot cast when going to the bank, applying for a travel visa, etc. Once I get my Patagonia itinerary ironed out a bit more, you'll be hearing from me! Thanks again for the comment.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

The Hazards of Coming Home: Moving Back In With Mom & Dad

Anne Merritt ponders the comforts and contradictions of... 

Buenos Aires Binge Eating 101

We gave Tom Gates 24 hours to eat as much as he could s... 

7 Ancient Exercises You Can Do Anywhere

Clear your mind, and feel better by giving just a few m... 

Essential Packing List for Pet Owners

Michelle Schusterman outlines what pet owners need to p... 

Stand-Up Paddle Surfing, Hurricane Style

Beginners, we suggest starting elsewhere.... 

America's Largest Climbing Gym Opens in Atlanta

Stone Summit has over 30,000 square feet of climbing su... 

3 Exercises for Free Divers

Expert free diving is almost Zen-like, a union between ... 

10 Tips For Managing Your Online Life While Traveling

... 

Logging Off: How to Deal With Internet Addiction

Think you're addicted to the internet? Admitting it is ... 

21 Iconic Places, a Century Ago and Today

The following photo essay shows 21 iconic places with p... 



Focus





Editor Blogs