“Effective Charity”: Begging for Problems?

07/8/08  Print This Post Print This Post    5 Comments   Popular   Written by Julie Schwietert
    Share

Every traveler has encountered the dilemma: To give or not to give when confronted by someone asking for money in the street or on public transport?

Though hard numbers are difficult to come by due to the varied definitions applied to beggars (are all people who are homeless beggars?), the mobility of beggars, and the fact that they are often overlooked in official censuses, governments and social service organizations estimate that the number of beggars around the world is increasing:

Vancouver: 1,000-1,200 beggars on the street at any given time.

Makassar: 2,600 street children and beggars counted in 2008, up from 870 in 2006.

Dakar: 100,000 street children reported in 2006.

And as begging has increased, so have local government and law enforcement efforts to curb the practice. In Makassar, for instance, citizens are banned from giving money to beggars. China and France have considered moving beggars permanently (though not into shelters or social service programs that work on root issues of begging and related social problems).

More innovative programs have been implemented, including street collection boxes in Aberdeen, Scotland, though many end in failure.

Still, Mexico City thinks it’s come up with the solution for street begging and the moral discomfort it raises in the prospective giver. The program “El amor nos une,” or “Love will unite us,” lets those who are tired of or uncomfortable with cash donations give coupons instead. The coupons, which the recipient can redeem for food, can be purchased at grocery stores throughout the city. Similar programs exist in Colombia and are planned for Chile.

But is “Love will unite us” just another band-aid that covers up the real problems that perpetuate poverty and begging? What’s your opinion? What other anti-begging strategies have you come across in your travels?

Want to learn more about how you can deal with begging during your travels? Check out Michaela Lola’s article, “Ten Ways You Can Help Street Children Without Giving Money,” over at Brave New Traveler.

Photo: Dey


    Share

About the Author

Matador ID: collazo

Julie Schwietert is the managing editor of Matador Network. She contributed a chapter to the recently published book, The Voluntary Traveler, and is currently working on five features for Fodor's Puerto Rico, 6th Edition.

5 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Eva replied on July 8, 2008

    Ottawa recently brought in "friendship meters" – white-painted parking meters in the downtown core, where residents are supposed to deposit their spare change that might otherwise go to individual pan-handlers. That way, the money goes directly to the shelters and food banks, rather than to, say, crack. The city also has a PR campaign letting people know that there *are* enough beds and meals available – no one is being turned away. So if someone tells you they're hungry and need cash for food…

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • collazoprojects replied on July 8, 2008

    Eva- Interesting! As a former social worker, I know that cities tend to have well-developed social service systems, but that many people on the street are reluctant to take advantage of those services–for lots of reasons, both legitimate and less so. As a wide-eyed transplant to New York, fresh with my first business card in hand, I was totally blown away when a guy came through a subway car and said "I'm homeless, I'm hungry, I have HIV, etc." I thought, "Perfect! My agency deals with all of those problems," and I handed him a card. He looked at me, spat, and threw the card down, saying "I don't want to go to no agency! I want money!" I became a lot more thoughtful about the complexities of begging after that!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Hal replied on July 8, 2008

    This is something that touches everyone's lives…not just travelers, but anyone who lives in an urban area. Personally, I don't like simply forking over cash, but I do it sometimes. If I have the time, I'll go pick up some food or water and bring it back instead. The next step would be to actually invite the person into a restaurant for a meal–I haven't quite worked up the courage to do that yet, but I bet I'd pick up some interesting stories! I like Mexico City's program. Yes, it's treating the symptoms of the problem instead of the cause, but often that's the most you can ask of individuals who aren't directly connected to the issue.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • sahadatu issaka replied on April 3, 2010

    I am sahadatu and i live in Ghana, Tamale to be precise. Am looking for a group/ individual whowill help me establish an ngo in Niger because we have frequent increase in school drop out in both sex since Education is the cornerstone of our socio-economic development, because the young children we are bringing up today shall become the bedrock of our very survival.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

The End of Evolution: Will Travel Become Obsolete?

According to an article on Daily Galaxy, we have moved ... 

10 Drink Recipes You Can Light On Fire

Put a shallow layer of 151-proof rum on top. Light the ... 

Travel Photographer Interviews - Mathieu Young

Matador Editor at Large Paul Sullivan talks with Mathei... 

How to be More Comfortable on Camera

Are you camera shy? Try some of these techniques to fee... 

John Lennon: The Lost 1969 Interview On Peace

38 years after it was recorded, an impromptu interview ... 

How To Know When You're NOT Ready To Pack Up & Go?

Just ask yourself two very simple questions.... 

Essential Packing List for Pet Owners

Michelle Schusterman outlines what pet owners need to p... 

Checklist for Writers: 10 Questions to Ask While Editing

10 questions to help when you're

Logging Off: How to Deal With Internet Addiction

Think you're addicted to the internet? Admitting it is ... 

5 Things You Can Do to Help Free the Hikers

Help free Matador contributor Sarah Shourd from an Iran... 



Focus





Editor Blogs